Pros and Cons of In-Floor Radiant Heating
Radiant flooring can be an efficient and effective way to heat your home. It has actually been around for centuries, but technology has improved to the point where it has become a viable and popular heating option for homes in the United States. There are two basic types of radiant floor heating to consider:
1. Electric Radiant Heat (most popular): Individual wires or wire mesh are sandwiched between the finish layer and the substrate.
Hydronic Radiant Heat and Radiant Air Floors: Hydronic
Radiant Heat uses hot water running through tubes under the floor, and
Radiant Air Floors use tubes of hot air running under the floor.
Basics of In-Floor Radiant Heat
Knowing some of these can help you determine if it’s even a possibility for you.
• Not just Electric Radiant Heat, but all of these use
electricity. Their use will have a cost factor.
• Floors can heat up to 95 degrees F. This might exceed some floors' tolerances.
• Electric radiant heating systems work best when installed under porcelain, ceramic, stone and marble flooring. These floors are excellent heat conductors, and do not expand or contract with heat, so they are resistant to any warping or cracking.
• Hardwood, vinyl and carpet do not work well with electric radiant heating because they are not good conductors of heat, and actually behave like insulators, blocking heat from the room.
All home heating options all have basic pros and cons, and these can help
you determine if you even want to use radiant floor heating:
• In-floor radiant heat systems directly heat the
intended area, and don’t lose heat as warm air travels through vents or
• They can last up to 35 years, longer than any furnace.
• They can be cost efficient because the heat radiates upward, making the entire room feel more comfortable, allowing a lower thermostat setting.
• They provide more flexibility in placing furniture around the room without concern for heat vents.
• Due to the lack of forced air, they are silent. This is also a benefit for allergy sufferers because dust, dirt, pollen and other allergens are not blown into the home.
• Eventually heat is evenly distributed throughout a room creating a feeling of warmth.
• They are an excellent option for heating home additions without having to extend HVAC ducts.
• Concrete will retain the heat for long periods of time after the power is turned off.
• Higher peak periods are those when people are home, evenings, weekends, etc. radiant heat can be used during off peak hours because its flooring sources retain the heat for longer periods of time, they are “conductors” of heat. Cheaper rates for off peak hours.
• The upfront cost may be higher than the cost of
replacing a furnace.
• Many contractors are not familiar with their installation, so you may have to look around to find a company that is experienced in the process.
• They are difficult to install retroactively, after a home or room has been built. It’s not impossible. Replacing the transmission in your car is also not impossible, but it is a big reason why people get new cars.
• Most floor coverings will list limitations on the temperatures at which radiant heating can be set. These are usually pretty reasonable, like “Not over 98 degrees,” but it is something you would have to look into when shopping for a floor.
• They are a slow-build heater, taking some time to warm up your home. The heat radiates into the floor and continues to spread upward, but not at the same velocity and speed as air forced through a vent. Ergo, they are more effective warmers of the floor than an entire home.
• The cost of repairs may be high because the heating coils or pipes which may need attention are located beneath the flooring.
• Their lack of ductwork is not efficient for cooling. Air conditioning in a radiant heated room is typically done with a heat pump or condenser separate from the radiant system
• A dehumidifier may be required to prevent condensation on the floor.
Always check with a professional if you’re considering installing radiant heat in your home. Building a new home, remodeling an existing property or building an addition are all great times to consider installing a radiant heating system, and it can be an important selling point for your home!
– – – –
David is has written and made videos about flooring products and installation since 2011 at Floors To Your Home (.com), where he is also the PPC Manager, a Researcher, a Website & Marketing Strategy Team member, Videographer, Social Strategist, Photographer and all around Resource Jito. In my spare time I shoot and edit video, put together a podcast, explore film history, and mix music (as in ‘play with Beatles multi-tracks’). Connect with W. David Lichty
Follow Team Floors To Your Home on Facebook